Spearmint Tea vs Peppermint Tea: What’s the Difference?

Spearmint Tea vs Peppermint Tea: What’s the Difference?

Quick answer: Spearmint and peppermint are different mint plants. Spearmint tea is sweeter, milder and softer. Peppermint tea is stronger, sharper and more cooling because it contains much more menthol. Both are caffeine-free.

Spearmint tea and peppermint tea use different mint plants. Their similar names can hide an important distinction when you are comparing ingredients or looking for a familiar flavour.

Close-up of green leaves
Tea image from the K&M Herbs collection.

Two botanical names

Spearmint is Mentha spicata. Peppermint is Mentha × piperita, a hybrid associated with spearmint and water mint. Kew records these botanical identities. They are related plants, but one name is not a substitute for the other.

A mint name can be broad

A packet labelled simply “mint tea” may need a closer look. It could use one mint ingredient or combine several. The full description can identify which plant is included and whether the tea also contains other herbs or flavourings.

Comparing the actual cups

For a taste comparison, the two products need their own preparation instructions. A plain mint infusion and a sweetened mint blend will not offer a fair comparison of the plants alone. Aroma, intensity and finish can all be part of your tasting notes.

Other directions to explore

Mint is only one branch of herbal tea. Readers who enjoy discovering individual ingredients can also explore lemongrass or Caribbean leaf teas. These are different options, not equivalents to spearmint or peppermint. This comparison is educational rather than a claim that K&M stocks either mint.

Background reading: Kew’s peppermint record.

More from K&M Herbs

Explore our current tea and gift range and download our free herbal tea and wellness book for more about K&M Herbs.

Related reading: What Is Single-Ingredient Herbal Tea?.

Spearmint and peppermint side by side

SpearmintPeppermint
PlantMentha spicataMentha × piperita (a hybrid of spearmint and water mint)
FlavourSweeter, softer, gentleStronger, sharper, very cooling
WhyLower in mentholHigh in menthol
CaffeineNoneNone
Often used inMoroccan mint tea, cookingAfter-dinner tea, sweets

How to brew mint tea

Use one bag or a small handful of fresh leaves per mug and freshly boiled water. Cover the cup, because mint’s flavour is in its oils and they escape with the steam. Brew for 3 to 5 minutes. Peppermint gets strong quickly, so taste it early.

Fresh or dried mint?

Fresh mint gives a lighter, greener cup. Dried mint is more concentrated, so you need less. To use fresh leaves, rinse a small handful, bruise them gently in your hand and pour hot water over them.

Mint with Caribbean teas

A few mint leaves work well with lemongrass for a fresh, cooling drink, hot or iced. Mint also lifts the tartness of hibiscus in an iced jug.

Which to choose

If you like…Try
A gentle, sweet mintSpearmint
A strong, cooling mintPeppermint
Mint with a citrus twistSpearmint with lemongrass
Moroccan-style mint teaSpearmint with green tea and sugar

Growing your own mint

Both are easy to grow in a pot on a windowsill or balcony. Keep them in containers, because mint spreads quickly in the garden. Pick the leaves just before you use them for the freshest flavour.

Storing mint tea

Dried mint keeps its flavour best in a sealed container away from heat and light. Fresh mint keeps for a few days in the fridge, wrapped in a damp paper towel or stood in a glass of water.

Iced mint tea

Brew 4 bags in 500ml of freshly boiled water for 5 minutes, remove them and let it cool. Top up with 500ml of cold water and serve over ice with lime and fresh mint leaves.

Frequently asked questions

Which mint tea is stronger?

Peppermint. Its higher menthol content gives a strong, cooling flavour.

Is spearmint tea sweeter than peppermint?

Yes. Spearmint is milder and naturally sweeter.

Can I blend mint with other herbal teas?

Yes. Mint pairs well with lemongrass and many leaf teas.

Is spearmint or peppermint better iced?

Both work. Spearmint is softer; peppermint is more cooling.

Does mint tea have caffeine?

No. Pure spearmint and peppermint teas are naturally caffeine-free.

Can I use garden mint for tea?

Yes, if you know what it is and it hasn’t been sprayed. Rinse the leaves first.

Does peppermint tea taste like toothpaste?

It has the same cool menthol flavour, but it’s softer and more herbal.

Shop the teas in this article