Quick answer: Black tea comes from the tea plant (Camellia sinensis) and contains caffeine. Herbal tea is made from other plants, like hibiscus, lemongrass or soursop leaves, so it is usually caffeine-free. Black tea is malty and brisk; herbal teas range from fruity and floral to earthy.
Herbal tea and black tea differ first in their ingredients. Black tea comes from the tea plant, Camellia sinensis, while herbal infusions use a much wider range of plant materials.

A plant name rather than a colour test
A dark herbal infusion is not automatically black tea. The word black identifies a tea style made from the tea plant, rather than any drink with a dark appearance. A turmeric or leaf infusion keeps its own ingredient identity regardless of the colour of the cup.
Where blended products fit
Some drinks combine tea-plant leaves with herbs or fruit. Those are different from a plain herbal infusion. Reading the complete list is useful when the front of a packet highlights one flavour but does not explain the whole formulation.
Compare flavour on its own terms
Black tea and a herbal infusion need not taste alike. Aroma, strength and finish give you practical comparison points. A familiar black-tea routine may include milk; that does not mean every herbal ingredient will suit the same additions.
Making a useful choice
Choose by the ingredient and the experience you want to explore, rather than by the darkness of the drink. Our caffeine guide provides a separate explanation of that question. This comparison does not rank one category as healthier than the other.
Background reading: UK Tea & Infusions Association.
More from K&M Herbs
Explore our current tea and gift range and download our free herbal tea and wellness book for more about K&M Herbs.
Related reading: Does Herbal Tea Contain Caffeine? What to Check.
Herbal tea and black tea side by side
| Black tea | Herbal tea | |
|---|---|---|
| Made from | Leaves of the tea plant, Camellia sinensis | Other plants: leaves, flowers, roots, bark |
| Caffeine | Yes | Usually none |
| Processing | Leaves are fully oxidised, which darkens them | Usually just dried |
| Flavour | Malty, brisk, sometimes astringent | Depends on the plant: citrusy, fruity, earthy, spicy |
| Water | Freshly boiled | Freshly boiled for most |
| Brewing time | 3 to 5 minutes | 5 to 10 minutes |
| Milk? | Commonly | Some (bay leaf, turmeric), not acidic ones like hibiscus |
Green, white and oolong are “real” tea too
Green, white, oolong and black teas all come from the same plant. The difference is how the leaves are processed. Anything made from a different plant, like lemongrass or hibiscus, is a herbal tea. Read more about caffeine-free herbal tea.
Switching from black tea to herbal
If you usually drink black tea with milk, try Caribbean bay leaf or turmeric with a splash of milk. If you drink it with lemon, try lemongrass or hibiscus. Starting with a similar style of drink makes the change easier.
How much caffeine is in black tea?
It varies with the tea and how long you brew it. Black tea contains less caffeine than the same amount of brewed coffee, but more than most herbal teas, which usually contain none. If you’re cutting down, swapping one or two cups a day for herbal tea is an easy start.
Brewing differences
Black tea can turn bitter and astringent if brewed too long, so 3 to 5 minutes is usual. Most herbal teas are more forgiving: they often need 5 to 10 minutes to give their full flavour. Read should you cover herbal tea for more brewing tips.
Mixing black and herbal tea
Some blends combine black tea with herbs, like black tea with mint or lemongrass. These contain caffeine because of the black tea. If you want none, choose a pure herbal tea.
Frequently asked questions
Does herbal tea have caffeine?
Most herbal teas are naturally caffeine-free. Check the ingredients if a blend includes black or green tea.
Can I drink herbal tea in the evening?
Many people prefer caffeine-free herbal teas in the evening for that reason.
Is herbal tea the same as green tea?
No. Green tea comes from the tea plant, like black tea, and contains caffeine.
Is black tea a herbal tea?
No. Black tea comes from the tea plant. Herbal teas come from other plants.
Which has more flavour, herbal or black tea?
Neither. They’re just different, and herbal teas cover a much wider range of flavours.
Is green tea a herbal tea?
No. Green tea comes from the tea plant and contains caffeine.
Shop the teas in this article
- Hibiscus Tea Bags – £8
- Lemongrass tea bags – £8
- Gift Pack – £14.80
