
Quick answer: No, green tea and Earl Grey are not herbal teas. Both are made from the leaves of the tea plant, Camellia sinensis, so they contain caffeine. Earl Grey is black tea flavoured with oil of bergamot, a citrus fruit. Herbal teas are made from other plants, such as lemongrass, hibiscus, chamomile or peppermint, and most are naturally caffeine-free.
The simple rule
If a drink is made from the leaves of Camellia sinensis, it’s “real” tea: black, green, white, oolong and pu-erh all come from this one plant. If it’s made from any other plant, it’s a herbal tea, also called a herbal infusion or tisane. Read what is herbal tea.
Is it herbal tea? A quick list
| Tea | Herbal? | Made from | Caffeine |
|---|---|---|---|
| Green tea | No | Tea plant, unoxidised | Yes |
| Black tea / English Breakfast | No | Tea plant, fully oxidised | Yes |
| Earl Grey | No | Black tea + bergamot oil | Yes |
| Lady Grey | No | Black tea + citrus | Yes |
| Matcha | No | Powdered green tea | Yes |
| Chai | Usually no | Black tea + spices | Yes (unless made with herbs) |
| Rooibos | Yes | South African red bush | No |
| Peppermint | Yes | Mint leaves | No |
| Chamomile | Yes | Dried flowers | No |
| Hibiscus | Yes | Dried calyces | No |
| Lemongrass | Yes | A tropical grass | No |
| Yerba mate | Yes | South American holly leaves | Yes, it’s an exception |
What about brands like Lipton or Twinings?
A brand name doesn’t tell you whether a tea is herbal. Big brands sell both. Lipton’s best-known tea is black tea, but it also sells herbal infusions; Twinings sells Earl Grey and English Breakfast alongside peppermint and camomile. Always check the ingredients list on the box.
How to check a label
- Look for “tea”, “black tea”, “green tea” or Camellia sinensis in the ingredients. If you see them, it isn’t a pure herbal tea.
- Words like “infusion”, “tisane” or “herbal” usually mean no tea plant, but check blends.
- “Naturally caffeine-free” is a good sign that it’s a herbal tea.
- Fruit teas are a kind of herbal tea, but some contain added black tea.
Herbal versions of familiar drinks
| If you like… | Try this herbal tea |
|---|---|
| Earl Grey (citrusy) | Lemongrass |
| Green tea (grassy, fresh) | Moringa |
| English Breakfast with milk | Caribbean bay leaf with a splash of milk |
| Fruit teas | Hibiscus |
See also herbal tea vs black tea and how much caffeine is in tea.
Why the confusion?
In everyday English, “tea” means almost any hot drink made by steeping something in water, so people naturally call peppermint or chamomile “tea”. Shops often put herbal and real teas on the same shelf, and many brands sell both. The names only tell you so much; the ingredients tell you the rest.
Green tea vs herbal tea at a glance
| Green tea | Herbal tea | |
|---|---|---|
| Plant | Camellia sinensis | Many different plants |
| Caffeine | Yes | Usually none |
| Water | Hot, not boiling (about 80°C) | Freshly boiled for most |
| Brewing time | 2–3 minutes | 5–10 minutes |
| Taste | Grassy, vegetal, can turn bitter | Depends on the plant |
Is fruit tea herbal tea?
Usually, yes. Fruit teas are made from dried fruit, flowers and herbs. Some contain added flavourings or black tea, so read the ingredients if you want a pure, caffeine-free drink.
Frequently asked questions
Is green tea a herbal tea?
No. Green tea comes from the tea plant, Camellia sinensis, and contains caffeine.
Is Earl Grey a herbal tea?
No. Earl Grey is black tea flavoured with bergamot oil.
Is Lipton a herbal tea?
Lipton is a brand. Its classic tea is black tea, but it also sells herbal infusions. Check the ingredients.
Is rooibos a herbal tea?
Yes. Rooibos comes from a South African plant, not the tea plant, and is caffeine-free.
Shop the teas in this article
- Lemongrass tea bags – £8
- Moringa tea bags – £8
- Caribbean Bay Leaf Teabags – £8
- Hibiscus Tea Bags – £8
