Hibiscus Tea: Is It the Same as Caribbean Sorrel?

Hibiscus Tea: Is It the Same as Caribbean Sorrel?

Quick answer: Hibiscus tea and Caribbean sorrel both come from the same plant, Hibiscus sabdariffa. Hibiscus tea is the plain ruby-red infusion of the dried calyces. Caribbean sorrel is a festive drink made from the same calyces, usually steeped with spices such as ginger, cloves and cinnamon and sweetened, especially at Christmas.

Hibiscus tea and Caribbean sorrel drinks can share a botanical ingredient, but their finished recipes may differ. Understanding the plant name and the recipe helps separate these two parts of the story.

K&M Herbs hibiscus tea packaging
Tea image from the K&M Herbs collection.

The name sorrel

Kew records names including Jamaican sorrel and red sorrel for Hibiscus sabdariffa. Common names can vary between places, and the word sorrel is also used for other plants. A botanical identity is more precise than the common name by itself.

Ingredient and finished drink

A hibiscus infusion may be prepared from a packaged hibiscus ingredient. A sorrel drink can be a family recipe with additional ingredients and its own serving style. Sharing an ingredient does not make every finished drink identical.

What changes the comparison?

Sweetness, spices and serving temperature can change the experience. A plain hibiscus cup and a sweetened, spiced drink are comparisons of recipes as well as ingredients. Naming those additions makes the distinction clearer.

Exploring your own cup

Our hibiscus tea bags and existing hot and iced serving guides offer a starting point for the packaged-tea side of this discussion. They do not represent every Caribbean family’s sorrel recipe. Regional names and personal traditions can sit alongside the information printed on a packet.

Background reading: Kew’s Hibiscus sabdariffa record.

More from K&M Herbs

Explore our current tea and gift range and download our free herbal tea and wellness book for more about K&M Herbs.

Related reading: Hibiscus Tea Bags: A Brewing and Serving Guide.

How Caribbean sorrel is made

Sorrel is a Christmas drink across much of the Caribbean, including Grenada, Jamaica and Trinidad. Recipes vary by family, but most follow the same pattern:

  1. Dried sorrel (hibiscus calyces) is put in a large pot with fresh ginger and whole spices such as cloves, cinnamon and sometimes allspice or orange peel.
  2. Boiling water is poured over, and the pot is covered and left to steep, often overnight.
  3. It is strained, sweetened with sugar, and chilled.
  4. Some households add rum or wine for adults.

Making a sorrel-style drink with hibiscus tea bags

Steep 4 hibiscus tea bags in 1 litre of freshly boiled water with a few slices of ginger, 3 or 4 cloves and a cinnamon stick for 20 to 30 minutes. Remove everything, sweeten to taste and chill. It’s lighter than traditional sorrel made from whole dried calyces, but it’s quick and has the same festive flavours.

Hibiscus tea vs sorrel at a glance

Hibiscus teaCaribbean sorrel
Made fromDried calyces of Hibiscus sabdariffaThe same calyces
SpicesUsually noneGinger, cloves, cinnamon and more
SweetenedUsually notYes
ServedHot or iced, any timeChilled, mainly at Christmas

Storing sorrel and hibiscus

Dried hibiscus and sorrel keep well in a sealed container away from light and damp. Once made, sorrel drink should be kept in the fridge and drunk within a few days, unless your family recipe preserves it with alcohol.

Hibiscus drinks around the world

The same plant makes agua de jamaica in Mexico, karkadé in Egypt and bissap in West Africa. Each has its own spices and sweetness, but they all share the bright red colour and tart taste. Read why hibiscus tea is red.

A non-alcoholic Christmas jug

Make the sorrel-style drink above, chill it, and top it up with sparkling water and orange slices just before serving. It makes a festive drink everyone can enjoy.

Frequently asked questions

Is sorrel the same as hibiscus?

In the Caribbean, “sorrel” means Hibiscus sabdariffa, the same plant used for hibiscus tea. It is not the leafy European herb also called sorrel.

Can I make sorrel with hibiscus tea bags?

Yes. Brew several bags strong, add spices like ginger and cloves, sweeten to taste and chill.

Is hibiscus tea caffeine-free?

Yes. Pure hibiscus contains no caffeine.

Is sorrel the same as the green sorrel leaf used in cooking?

No. Garden sorrel (Rumex) is a leafy green herb. Caribbean sorrel is hibiscus.

Why is sorrel a Christmas drink?

Roselle is traditionally harvested in the Caribbean around the end of the year, so sorrel became part of Christmas celebrations.

How long does homemade sorrel keep?

In the fridge, a few days. Keep it covered.

Shop the teas in this article